From writer Joni Hagg and co-author & artist Stipan Morian (20th Century Men) comes a grimy, Dickensian take on a holiday story with Our Soot Stained Heart #1. Featuring Ropemann on colors and letting from Hassan Otsmane-Elhaou, this opening issue is a beautifully crafted comic book that may be the most interesting take on a Christmas story in many years – in any medium. With a stunningly poetic script and phenomenal visual work, Our Soot Stained Heart is one of the best debut comics of the year.
“The Coalition is a city of wonder in the deep north, but it is ruled by the cruel Governor Glass and his factory lords. Coal is the lifeline of the city, and for honest workers like young Peggy Stones, life can be hard because of the nefarious quota. To get extra coal at the end of the year, you must be bad, every day! Peggy’s life is thrown into chaos when she is imprisoned and sent into exile, which begins a harrowing journey to the ends of the world to find answers that could change the world!”
Writing & Plot
Joni Hagg and Stipan Morian craft an entrancing, poetic take on a wintry tale in the pages of Our Soot Stained Heart #1. The pair immediately take to crafting their own lore about this coal covered, corrupt town where the poor work for less and less every day while the rich get richer. Within the framework of this familiar story is where the magic happens. Hagg’s scripting is so poetic and thoughtful that even the most familiar and tropey of lines feel brand new and natural to this world. What starts off as a girl trying to work and live on her own turns into a tale of revolution on the road to answers. As we’re drip-fed information about this world – the Coalition, the Baron, Quotas, Peggy’s family – it never devolves into exposition. Everything the reader needs to understand the story is supplied through the carefully crafted narrative. This makes the story feel all the more organic, like we’re reading a poetic tapestry of fable rather than a more plainly written comic. The dialogue and Peggy’s overhead narration weave seamlessly throughout the issue, providing both texture to the world and more depth to our protagonist and her backstory. As far as takes on Dickensian tales of winter woe, Our Soot Stained Heart is on track to be one of the absolute best in terms of written storytelling.

Art Direction
Of course, what takes Our Soot Stained Heart #1 to the next level of comics greatness is Stipan Morian‘s incredible visual work. The 20th Century Men artist & co-creator demonstrates the full range of his creativity with a constantly shifting art style and creative sequential direction. Morian’s approach to world and character design makes this book feel almost timeless, like it could just as well be an Avant Garde French comic from the 70’s as it is a contemporary holiday tale. He brings a brutal, classically Dickensian vision of a coal burning industrial city to life in possibly the best way its’s ever been done in a comic. He then sharply contrasts this with the equally brutal pure white of the snowy tundra the latter part of the book takes place in. Morian’s character animations and action sequences have an excitement and fluidity seldom seen in comics anymore, and that’s even among big mainstream superhero books. His sequential direction ranges from classic, detail-focused blocks to weaving images over each other on a massive unbroken spread, in an effort to demonstrate the passage of time for a single character. My favorite visual moment in the comic (even though they’re all incredible) is a page where Morian completely changes his style into a sort of Herge’s Tin-Tin tribute, and it works perfectly in the book. I actually let out a gleeful chuckle. Morian’s work is bolstered by Ropemann’s stellar color art, which echoes the variety of approaches the pencils take. Backgrounds are a stunning mix of atmospheric the help craft the tones of desperation and hope this comic swings between. You can feel the heat of the furnaces and the biting cold of the snow as you read through each page of the comic. The color art also shifts drastically in approach from the current-time action to the more dreamlike flashbacks Morian takes us on. The impeccable cherry on top of the reading experience comes in the form of Hassan Otsmane-Elhaou’s lettering, and the longtime industry pro may have done his best work yet in the pages of Our Soot Stained Heart. From the classical storybook-esque approach of the narrative lettering to the constantly surprising and reactive dialogue lettering, Hassan’s lettering work here is just as dynamic as the rest of the visual experience. The SFX works perfectly and matches the art and the action in-panel (my favorite is a big WHOOSH of a train going by), and there seems to be no shortage of types of fonts used for every scenario this story comes up with. Visually, Our Soot Stained Heart is a nearly-unmatched work of brilliance.
Verdict
Our Soot Stained Heart #1 is actually a bit of a difficult comic to review, solely because it feels like it’s playing on a completely different level of creativity than most comics I’ve read in recent memory. Joni Hagg and Stipan Morian’s story is a compelling, thematically deep take on Dickensian wintry woe that still sings with hope. The visual work from Morian, Ropemann, and Hassan Otsmane-Elhaou is executed on a masterful level in every regard, giving this comic a timeless effect. Be sure to grab this incredible debut issue when it hits shelves on December 10th!



















































