Review: A Classic Villain Is Given a New Mask In YEAR OF THE VILLAIN: BLACK MASK #1


YEAR OF THE VILLAIN: BLACK MASK #1 puts a smart new spin on a classic Bat-villain that greatly needed an updated mask. Furthermore YEAR OF THE VILLAIN: BLACK MASK #1 works as a great tie-in but as an even greater stand alone for newcomers.   
- Advertisement -

Have you ever wanted the power to wear any face like a mask? If so, what would you do? Become a kingpin? Return as the king of the underworld? Gain money and power? Or would build an empire and shape the course of history? This being one of many questions Black Mask has to answer in DC Comics’ Year of The Villain: Black Mask #1, out this week (check your local comic book store).

Black Mask was originally introduced in 1985 but hasn’t been seen around as often as other Bat-villains. He has been lucky enough to be included in multiple media formats, but never in the forefront as the others in the Dark Knight’s rogue gallery. Funny enough he is known more for his run ins with Catwoman in Ed Brubaker and Cameron Stewart’s amazing Catwoman series.

Having been portrayed throughout his comic history as a ruthless crime lord who loves torture as much as masks, he has never been anything more than a normal human. That character trait changes with Tom Taylor’s Year of The Villain: Black Mask #1. Although it’s labeled as a Year of The Villain tie-in no info for the event is needed, other than Lex can give other powers.

Review: A Classic Villain Is Given a New Mask In YEAR OF THE VILLAIN: BLACK MASK #1 1

- Advertisement -

Having Black Mask #1 act as a tie-in while having it essentially a stand alone works to it’s benefit for readers interested in said character. This shows DC’s great marketing strategy with the Birds of Prey movie releasing next year with Black Mask as the villain. This movie will mark his live-action debut while also marking Renee Montoya debut, who DC has also pushed lately.

Dedicating the first nine pages as a retelling of Black Mask’s history, Taylor gives the audience a quick backstory so they learn what is needed without having to read other stories. This retelling is told from none other than Black Mask as he holds a bank teller hostage. Taylor could have easily made this opening boring, but instead played it off with Black Mask wanting to finally talk to someone; so why not tell you origin? With the backstory for newcomers done we make our way to the Year of The Villains aspect, enter Lex Luthor.

Helping Black Mask escape from the bank Lex promises him whatever he desires, as long as he takes power from Lex. What best to go with a mask obsessed villain than the power to change your face? As great as this power is it’s never defined how it works. Is it like One Piece’s Bon Kurei where he needs to first touch the person? Or like the dozen other shapeshifters where he just needs to see a picture?

Review: A Classic Villain Is Given a New Mask In YEAR OF THE VILLAIN: BLACK MASK #1 2

Besides the question of how his powers works, Taylor crafts a superb new origin story that builds upon Black Masks history while making him more accessible. While the issue is titled after Black Mask it features a heavy dose of Batwoman teaming with Renee Montoya. As previously stated DC has been pushing Montoya often lately, but this works out for the best in most cases. As did Lois Lane having Montoya team up with her, the same concept applied here is a smart idea to bring to the public’s eye. On the subject of eye’s, how about that art?

On a visual level Black Mask #1 comes off as an adult cartoon turned into a comic with pencils by Cully Hamner. This style gels quite well with the story being told but wasn’t as such from the get-go. For Black Masks flashback of his younger years he has a misshapen face, at first you think this is done on purpose, but once young Bruce comes into panel he looks the same. It’s not story breaking, but it’s very noticeable when one side of a character’s face is slumping down like melted butter.

This face slumping happens a few more times in the present but nothing as jarring as the last segment. The rest of the pencils look great with Hamner making great use of paneling for dialogue and in a few action sequences, well that is true except one instance. Although it is drawn quite well and has a smart use of coloring in the panel, there is a slap scene early on that seems to break the laws of physics.

Review: A Classic Villain Is Given a New Mask In YEAR OF THE VILLAIN: BLACK MASK #1 3

Yes comics can break this law (and others), but that’s for those with powers; in this case, it’s Black Masks father (Richard Sionis). Angry at his son he lashes out with a slap so forceful the colors of the panel turn black and red, thanks to Dave Stewart’s stimulating emotions with colors. Richard smacks Roman (Black Mask) with his left hand moving right to left connecting violently to Roman’s left side face.

If you’re visualizing this you’re probably thinking Roman’s head would turn to the right as he falls. That would be how it should happen, but sadly it doesn’t, instead his head (and body) flies to the left making no sense. This is a minor problem in what was otherwise a well-drawn issue, plus this physics breaking has occurred in comics before.

Helping emphasize on certain scenes and emotions is Stewart’s fantastic eye catching colors that are bright and lively when needed and dark somber moods in others. Stewart’s colors hammer home the smack Roman receives (even with the physics problems already said) and the loud BANG that fills the panel when Black Mask shoots a gun.

Review: A Classic Villain Is Given a New Mask In YEAR OF THE VILLAIN: BLACK MASK #1 4

A Black Mask Affair (Conclusion)

Taylor writes a great Black Mask, granted it would have been nice to see his brutal torture methods he’s famous for but the story being told didn’t warrant that. As great as the Black Mask moments are the Batwoman and Montoya moments outshine the titular character. The two heroes have a great chemistry that Taylor and team play upon making it a blast anytime they are together.

Combining the great blend of story shifting, the art and colors makes Year of The Villain: Black Mask #1 perfect for those new to the character, or those already invested in Year of The Villain.k

Memorable Quote: “Well, that’s dark. But to each their own.” – Lex Luthor

Coming from Lex Luthor, that’s pretty hilarious!

Dear Reader Behind The Mask

If your now joining in on DC’s Year of The Villain then check out some coverage from the beginning of the year to catch yourself up! Or if your a newcomer interested in Black Mask or a fan already caught up that wants to read this Bat-tastic issue then check your local comic store!

Save 50% on graphic novels, statues & more!


G.I. JOE #1 Is a Joe-Tastic Start For New Readers

This Wednesday the action-packed first issue of IDW's newly rebooted G.I. Joe releases, where everyone can be a Joe, even you! The G.I. Joe comic...

Review: YOU ARE OBSOLETE #1 – A Leisurely Stroll Through Secluded Hell

The children are smart, clever, and are creepy as @#$% in You Are Obsolete #1, out this week from Aftershock. You Are Obsolete #1 is...

Review: THE BLACK GHOST#1 Excellently Mixes Noir, Mystery and Vigilantes

The Black Ghost #1, published by ComiXology, and created by Alex Segura, Monica Gallagher, Marco Finnegan, George Kambadias, Ellie Wright and Taylor Esposito perfectly...

A Dark King Rises In ONCE & FUTURE #2

Once & Future #2 continues the warped legend of King Arthur. This is a story that will leave you looking for more while chilling you to the bone.

A Dark and Deadly Tale Begins In NOMEN OMEN #1

Nomen Omen #1 is the start of a dark and disturbing series from Image Comics. It's a tale of the supernatural coming after what is their due, and so much more.

HOUSE OF X #5 – Get Ready For Your Mind To Be Blown

This week Marvel's mutant mania continues with HOUSE OF X #5. Jonathan Hickman's brain keeps spilling brilliance right into our hearts and minds, this chapter is particularly creative.

Review: The Cavalry Arrives In ABSOLUTE CARNAGE #3

Absolute Carnage #3 continues the series’ exceptional start and the whole team continues to impress

GUARDIANS OF THE GALAXY #9 – The Universal Chuch Of Action

This week Marvel unleashes GUARDIANS OF THE GALAXY #9 upon their faithful cosmic followers. Donny Cates delivers another heavy metal soaked script that artist Cory Smith packages in a fast-paced and action-packed issue.
Jason Jeffords Jr
Jason Jeffords Jr
Jason resides in the cold crime-ridden town of Anchorage, Alaska. When he isn't running away from murderers, he "chills" at home reading comics/books, watching films/TV, and playing video games with his three-legged cat Lucky. Oh he also sometimes writes for websites such as Monkeys Fighting Robots, Comics Bulletin, and Witll.


If you want your BUSINESS to be part of something bigger than itself, you might be a good fit to partner with Monkeys Fighting Robots.

Review: A Classic Villain Is Given a New Mask In YEAR OF THE VILLAIN: BLACK MASK #1 8


Review: A Classic Villain Is Given a New Mask In YEAR OF THE VILLAIN: BLACK MASK #1 9

Are you a creator looking for a review of your book?
Use the form below to end us a message.

Are you a fan of the website and have a comment, question, or concern? Drop us a line, and we will gladly answer all your questions.


Monkeys Fighting Robots is looking for passionate writers to drive the site’s coverage of the comic book industry. Authors will be responsible for a particular niche, providing reviews, opinion and news coverage, while building a reader community using his or her multimedia storytelling skills. The best candidates have solid writing skills, WordPress knowledge, and are engaged on social media. Do you love comic books and have a strong opinion, then we would like to speak with you.

Review: A Classic Villain Is Given a New Mask In YEAR OF THE VILLAIN: BLACK MASK #1 10


COMIC REVIEW DIGEST, sign up today! At Monkeys Fighting Robots, we strive to talk about ALL aspects of a comic book, instead of just giving you a recap of the story.
  • Did you notice how epic the colors were?
  • That was a wicked panel layout by the artist!
  • What was the letterer thinking?
  • How did this comic book make you feel?
  • Most importantly, should you buy it?

Every Wednesday you will receive an email with our latest reviews and analyses, as well as our original comic strips and exclusive editorial content.
Thanks for signing up!