Review: STAR TREK YEAR FIVE #5 Reinventing A True Classic


For fans of the Star Trek franchise, this comic is the best to be released in a long time. The creators have captured the essence of Star Trek and presented it in a fun and exciting way, even if the story itself may seem familiar.
- Advertisement -

With Jody Houser taking over the writing duties on Star Trek Year Five, IDW Publishing have a master of science fiction storytelling on their hands. Heavily influenced by the 1960’s style of Star Trek, the latest issue out this week continues the run on familiar stories told in a modern way.

Star Trek Year Five #5 reinventing a true classic
Star Trek Year Five #5 Credit: IDW Publishing

Bygone Years

Landing on a desolate planet, the Enterprise away team embarks on an archaeological survey. They collect a few artefacts to transport back to Earth for investigation but Dr Bennett, the archaeologist amongst them, believes they are missing a rare chance for discovery.

Agreeing with her up to a point, Captain Kirk ponders on the alien life they already have on board: The Tholian they have nicknamed Bright Eyes.

- Advertisement -

After leaving the planet’s surface the crew return to their usual routine however a strange force begins affecting the crew. Tempers become frayed and patience seems be running out. Minor instances start to escalate and it’s not long before everyone appears affected.

With this issue of Year Five Houser has written a classic Star Trek story. Similar in concept to the Original Series episode, The Naked Time, and its Next Generation follow up, The Naked Now, the main premise deals with a cabin fever type situation. The crew of the star ship are trapped in close proximity to each other, living in each other’s shadows, unable to get away. Houser uses small breakouts to identify the problem, making it clear that these confrontations are bubbling just beneath the surface and it only takes a small unexplained nudge to bring it all out.

As the plot thickens, so does the intensity of the disagreements. The script reflects the frustration and resentment within the crew members and Houser draws attention to moments where the cast act out of character: for example, during the senior officers meeting there are some oddities within the conversation that makes the reader re-read several panels. This is intentional and is a way of highlighting the problem the Enterprise crew face.

Houser has a clear understanding of the characters and captures their voices and mannerisms wonderfully. The gently conversation between Kirk and Uhura is contrasted with the ‘boyish’ banter between the male officers. This type of behaviour was evident in the original T.V. series and Houser makes it work during this story without it seeming out dated.

STAR TREK YEAR FIVE #5 Reinventing A True Classic
Star Trek Year Five #5 Credit: IDW Publishing

Illustrating Trek

Silvia Califano uses fine inked lines to create detailed character work. There is an element of claustrophobia to her panels which mirrors the underlying theme of the narrative. The back grounds are sparse and often reflect the coldness between the cast members in the foreground. With the color assist from Thomas Deer some of the panels even take on the heightened emotions of the characters, alternating for a brief moment from cold greys to stark oranges or reds and back again.

These flashes of emotion drive the story forward and illustrate how out of character the regulars are. This impression is also given in the way that Califano handles the panel boarders. Occasionally the panels become small slivers behind the character or the boarders are irregular signalling to the reader that there is something amiss.

Because of this focus on characters there is a lot of space for Neil Uyetake to place his lettering. His speech balloons occupy the empty space but do not fill it. They are often subtle with small amounts of text in speech balloons that hover over a vast block of color. They almost become swamped by the emptiness around them and this has the opposite effect than a large, screaming word balloon. The speech is amplified by the background, almost like an awkward pause before someone speaks.

It is clear from the opening that this story is going to be about the crew, trapped together on the Enterprise with disaster lurking just around the corner. The panel layouts; the block, expressive coloring; and the tightly controlled lettering, all build the impression of a crew under pressure, a kettle reaching boiling point.

STAR TREK YEAR FIVE #5 Reinventing A True Classic
Star Trek Year Five #5 Credit: IDW Publishing


Houser has written for a number of science fiction franchises and she has an ability to get to the heart of the characters very quickly. She draws on their strengths and weaknesses to move the narrative on, knowing exactly who to put in each scene. The interactions between the main crew in Star Trek Year Five are perfect representations of the characters we all know and love. These are then illustrated with such fine precision by Califano.

The story is not original, not in general science fiction or even in Star Trek but this is irrelevant because the creators of Star Trek Year Five are telling their story in such a fun and exciting way. Small character moments make this issue a joy to read and there is also the ongoing Tholian story-line that is always central to what is happening aboard the Enterprise.

Each new creative team they bring onto Star Trek Year Five has made the comic their own while at the same time producing something that is simply Star Trek. This series, and this issue in particular, has included some of the best Star Trek moments in recent years. If you only read one Star Trek comic this year, it definitely has to be this one.

Save 50% on graphic novels, statues & more!


Review: SUPERGIRL #34 Crashing Back To Earth In Style

This is a return to form in Supergirl #34 from DC Comics, with a creative team who are comfortable working together. Back to Earth and back to basics.

Review: It’s Alive’s PINK LEMONADE Mashes Kirby & Knievel

It takes a special kind of talent to be retro without being repetitive. Too often comics that harken back to the Silver Age just...

Review: THE BLACK GHOST#1 Excellently Mixes Noir, Mystery and Vigilantes

The Black Ghost #1, published by ComiXology, and created by Alex Segura, Monica Gallagher, Marco Finnegan, George Kambadias, Ellie Wright and Taylor Esposito perfectly...

Lobo’s Kid Snaps In Our Exclusive First Look At TEEN TITANS #34

Teen Titans #34 hits your local comic book store on September 18, but thanks to DC Comics, Monkeys Fighting Robots has an exclusive five-page...

HOUSE OF X #5 – Get Ready For Your Mind To Be Blown

This week Marvel's mutant mania continues with HOUSE OF X #5. Jonathan Hickman's brain keeps spilling brilliance right into our hearts and minds, this chapter is particularly creative.

Frank Miller And The Dark Knight: Together Again

He's currently chronicling the adventures of the Man of Steel in Superman Year One, but it seems Frank Miller's heart will always bring him...

AfterShock Exclusive Preview: BAD RECEPTION #2 – OMG, The HORROR! 😱🔪🔪

Bad Reception #2 hits your local comic book store on September 25, but thanks to AfterShock Comics, Monkeys Fighting Robots has a four-page preview...

Meet The Next Guardians Of The Galaxy In BLACK PANTHER AND THE AGENTS OF WAKANDA #1

You might not know a lot about the Agents of Wakanda right now but it’s only a matter of time before some of them become breakout stars. 
Darryll Robson
Darryll Robson
Comic book reader, reviewer and critic. Waiting patiently for the day they announce 'Doctor Who on The Planet of the Apes'.


Please enter your comment!
Please enter your name here

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.


If you want your BUSINESS to be part of something bigger than itself, you might be a good fit to partner with Monkeys Fighting Robots.

Review: STAR TREK YEAR FIVE #5 Reinventing A True Classic 3


Review: STAR TREK YEAR FIVE #5 Reinventing A True Classic 4

Are you a creator looking for a review of your book?
Use the form below to end us a message.

Are you a fan of the website and have a comment, question, or concern? Drop us a line, and we will gladly answer all your questions.


Monkeys Fighting Robots is looking for passionate writers to drive the site’s coverage of the comic book industry. Authors will be responsible for a particular niche, providing reviews, opinion and news coverage, while building a reader community using his or her multimedia storytelling skills. The best candidates have solid writing skills, WordPress knowledge, and are engaged on social media. Do you love comic books and have a strong opinion, then we would like to speak with you.

Review: STAR TREK YEAR FIVE #5 Reinventing A True Classic 5


COMIC REVIEW DIGEST, sign up today! At Monkeys Fighting Robots, we strive to talk about ALL aspects of a comic book, instead of just giving you a recap of the story.
  • Did you notice how epic the colors were?
  • That was a wicked panel layout by the artist!
  • What was the letterer thinking?
  • How did this comic book make you feel?
  • Most importantly, should you buy it?

Every Wednesday you will receive an email with our latest reviews and analyses, as well as our original comic strips and exclusive editorial content.
Thanks for signing up!