Review: STAR TREK YEAR FIVE Is Destined To Be A Classic


Star Trek Year Five is an epic adventure which boldly goes forth with style. This comic will warm the hearts of the original series fans while captivating a new audience.
- Advertisement -

As more information slowly trickles out about the new Star Trek T.V. series, IDW Publishing continues to keep the Trek audience entertained with titles such as Star Trek Year Five. Acting as an homage to the original series and a companion to the number of live action versions readily available, Star Trek Year Five is pure indulgence for any Star Trek fan.

STAR TREK YEAR FIVE #2 Is Destined To Be A Classic
Star Trek Year Five #2 Credit: IDW Publishing


After rescuing the only survivor of a massacre on an unexplored planet, Captain Kirk and the crew of the Enterprise face a Tholian threat which, if handled incorrectly, could start an interstellar war.

With the end of their mission so close, should Captain Kirk play it safe or stand his ground? How much is one life worth?

- Advertisement -

These are the questions that Jackson Lanzing and Collin Kelly ask in the second issue of Star Trek Year Five and they lead to some deep, sociological conversations. The original Star Trek series was always about ethical dilemmas and shining a light on society; Lanzing and Kelly have adopted this approach and there are a number of contemplative moments.

The script is speech heavy for the majority of the comic but it suits the type of story being told. This is Classic Star Trek and it is presented as such. It is a comforting contrast to the super-fast, action heavy versions audiences are faced with at the cinema or on T.V. That doesn’t mean Year Five isn’t exciting, it just has a different approach, inspired by Gene Roddenberry’s initial concept.

Lanzing and Kelly have captured the characters perfectly, so much so that you can hear the actors voice as you are reading. Their accents and inflections are woven into their speech so the reader can tell who is talking even when they are off panel.

STAR TREK YEAR FIVE #2 Is Destined To Be A Classic
Star Trek Year Five #2 Credit: IDW Publishing


The wonderful character representation is also reflected in Stephen Thompson’s art work. He uses very precise, thin pencil lines to shape the figures and scenery, allowing for an impressive amount of detail. The visual style is clearly inspired by the original series and the images make you feel as though you are back in the 60’s watching the show on television.

Thompson uses the scenery to create frames within the panels thereby giving the scenes some depth. It also allows Thompson to lead the reader through the panels and across the page. The layouts are fairly standard, and there is a lot of exposition to fit in, so Thompson uses his framing techniques with shifting camera angles to drive the story forward.  The pacing of the comic comes from the changing panel shapes with the occasional page bleed punctuating moments of significance.

Both Charlie Kirchoff, on colors, and Neil Uyetake, on letters, follow the aesthetic set by Thompson. Kirchoff uses muted colors to give the pages that 1960’s atmosphere but emphasises the uniforms worn by the Enterprise crew. This is almost as important for the characters as their speech.

Uyetake spaces the speech balloons out, giving each sentence or paragraph space to breath. The information is laid out in a naturalistic, conversational way but still conjures up memories of watching the staged Original Series episodes.

STAR TREK YEAR FIVE #2 Is Destined To Be A Classic
Star Trek Year Five #2 Credit: IDW Publishing


Star Trek Year Five is everything you could want from a Star Trek comic. It allows itself some indulgence in nostalgia, and references the Original series on a number of occasions, but not enough to make it just for fans. The central story is a strong, important story which can be read on a number of levels. On the surface it is a straight forward Sci-Fi romp with impending destruction around every corner but underneath there is a greater philosophy.

It is only two issues in but Star Trek Year Five is already shaping up to be a classic Star Trek comic, destined to be talked about for years to come.


Review: UNEARTH #1 – Plunging Into a New Horror Series

Something is clearly not right in the small Mexican town of Mitlán Itzá as Unearth #1 sets the stage for a twisted blend of...

Review: We Could Use a Few More Pages for THE QUIET KIND

In many ways, The Quiet Kind by Chuck Brown, with art by Jeremy Treece and Kelly Williams, is an inversion of the clichéd “chosen...

Review: RESONANT #1 A Sensational Way To End The World

Intriguing and exciting in equal measure, Resonant from Vault Comics has plenty to keep a reader engaged. A masterful first issue and a must read.


Wonder Woman Come Back to Me #1 is a reprinting of a classic tale of Diana once again diving into danger to save those she loves.

Review: DEAD END KIDS #1 Is A Somber Murder Mystery

Dead End Kids #1 is the new book from Source Point Press, written by Frank Gogol, with artwork by Nenad Cviticanin and letters by...

The Joker Gets Two New Comics In October

Fans of DC's Clown Prince of Crime got some big news this week: two new Joker projects are hitting the stands this October (joining...

Review: THE IMMORTAL HULK #21 Explores The History Of General Fortean

James Fortean, much like his mentor General Thunderbolt Ross, would like nothing more than to destroy both Bruce Banner and the Hulk. So much...

Review: SERA AND THE ROYAL STARS #1 A Mysterious Magical Mythos

Have you ever wished Aladdin was a bit more violent and had dragons? Well, Sera and the Royal Stars is what you've been hoping...
Darryll Robson
Darryll Robson
Comic book reader, reviewer and critic. Waiting patiently for the day they announce 'Doctor Who on The Planet of the Apes'.
COMIC REVIEW DIGEST, sign up today! At Monkeys Fighting Robots, we strive to talk about ALL aspects of a comic book, instead of just giving you a recap of the story.
  • Did you notice how epic the colors were?
  • That was a wicked panel layout by the artist!
  • What was the letterer thinking?
  • How did this comic book make you feel?
  • Most importantly, should you buy it?

Every Wednesday you will receive an email with our latest reviews and analyses, as well as our original comic strips and exclusive editorial content.
Thanks for signing up!