Review: All Aboard For STAR TREK THE Q CONFLICT #2


With a vast cast of characters The Q Conflict has the potential for greatness. Unfortunately, this second issue does not build on the concepts of the first issue and the story just doesn't pick up speed. Great Art fills the pages but it has no story to tell.
- Advertisement -

While Star Trek: Discovery is storming across T.V. screens, the rest of the franchise has been brought together by IDW Publishing to do battle for the enjoyment of Q and his eternal friends.  The second issue of The Q Conflict has a range of covers highlighting the mix of the crews and defines the format that the story is most likely to take for the rest of the series.

Drawing influence from other crossover event type stories, such as the original Secret Wars from Marvel comics and the multi Doctor stories from Doctor Who, The Q Conflict takes on the shape of a competition, pitting the crew of various space vessels against each other. The purpose is yet unstated and the prize a bigger mystery. But when Q is involved, nothing is going to be as it seems.

The Q Conflict #2 Credit: IDW Publishing
The Q Conflict #2 Credit: IDW Publishing


Scott and David Tipton open this issue with the awkwardness of a schoolyard team picking experience. Most of the crew have been separated out between the godlike beings and only Quark and Ensign Kim remain to be picked. Is this a comment on the popularity of these characters? Maybe.

- Advertisement -

But this moment is quickly passed and the meat of the story begins. Q sets out the rules, with a few choice inputs from Picard, and sets the goal for the first part of the game. What follows is the attainment on this goal by the competing crews and the first stage of The Q Conflict is underway.

As the story plods along, a number of the characters are spotlighted for a moment of emotion or character statement. Ensign Chekov is frustrated; Commander Worf is uncomfortable; and Riker is smug. Most of these character aspects will be known to the readers as it’s hard to believe that anyone reading this isn’t a fan of Star Trek. Therefore, these moments are unnecessary and read as such. It is possible it will lead to important story points later in the series but for now they hang in the narrative like an immobile space craft.

The aim of this issue is to establish to crew rosters and layout the ground work for the ‘game’ they are being forced to play. The Tipton’s have taken a very straightforward approach to this which means that the outcome is a touch bland. There is no real threat to overcome and each crew seem to be on a jolly jaunt rather than fighting for the safety of the universe.  Ultimately, the comic follows a group of people racing against each other for a ball. It lacks drama and suspense.

Unlike a crossover event like Marvel’s Secret Wars where heroes and villains are pitted against each other in the game, The Q Conflict has nothing but heroes and therefore at this moment it doesn’t matter who wins. There is scope here for some challenging storytelling, especially as the characters come into real conflict with each other, but this issue is lacking any of that.

There is an exciting narrative hovering on the horizon, the readers just aren’t allowed to go there yet.

The Q Conflict #2 Credit: IDW Publishing
The Q Conflict #2 Credit: IDW Publishing


The panel layouts from this second issue of The Q Conflict are thoughtfully designed. They lead the reader through the narrative and make it clear exactly which ship and crew each panel relates to. This is important for a comic like this because, in essence, everything is up in the air. The panel layouts ground the reader and focuses each location with its array of characters.

David Messina draws superb likenesses of the star ships crews and clearly has knowledge of each element of the franchise. He produces detailed work for Elisabetta D’Amico to ink and Alessandra Alexakis to color. Between them they create characters full of expression and emotion which is quite a challenge with the script they have been given.

The page layouts establish the location and the characters beautifully. The art team then build on this to make the comic endearing and provide an element of entertainment. The overall aesthetic is that of a Next Generation episode which is much warmer and comforting than the latest film franchise or Discovery.

The script is tedious in places and over written but Neil Uyetake manages to break this down in his lettering and make it flow across the pages. It’s easy to see who is speaking even if it’s not always clear from the dialogue itself. An easy to follow narrative is an important aspect of the comic which is helped by speech balloon placement.

The Q Conflict looks much better than it reads and it is a shame that the art team did not have a more exciting story to work their magic on.

The Q Conflict #2 Credit: IDW Publishing
The Q Conflict #2 Credit: IDW Publishing


A collection of easy in jokes and a lacklustre story means that The Q Conflict doesn’t live up to the potential of the first issue. The presentation is wonderful with artwork that captures the essence of a Star Trek episode but there is very little to back it up. This means that the flaws are more noticeable and any quirks are over enhanced.

Elements of the story and appearances from some characters will appeal to long term fans of the franchise. There is still potential in this series to tell an outstanding, genre busting story and as the series unfolds, this may yet come to fruition. For now, this chapter simply sets the scene in an adequate if uninspired way.



30+ Page Preview Of IDW’s SONS OF CHAOS From Chris Jaymes And Alejandro Aragon

The oversized, panoramic graphic novel Sons Of Chaos written by Chris Jaymes with art by Alejandro Aragon hits your local comic book shop on...

Review: Immigrants From The Sea Arrive In Amnesty Bay In AQUAMAN #50

Arthur Curry has fought elemental beings, befriended gods and goddesses, and regained painful memories of his accidental death at the hands of Mera, all...

Review: GIDEON FALLS #15 Andrea Sorrentino’s Art Will Give You Nightmares

Gideon Fall #15 from Image Comics hits your local comic book store today; written by Jeff Lemire, with art by Andrea Sorrentino, colors by...

Review: UNEARTH #1 – Plunging Into a New Horror Series

Something is clearly not right in the small Mexican town of Mitlán Itzá as Unearth #1 sets the stage for a twisted blend of...

How Enemies Are Turned to Friends in FIREFLY #8

Joss Whedon's Firefly has brought the crew new and unique problems. And Firefly #8 simply proves that the Browncoats will always find fascinating allies.

2019 Will Eisner Award Winners – The Complete List

The 2019 Will Eisner Awards were held last night at San Diego Comic-Con, and we have your complete list of winners below!

Review: The Queen Returns with VAMPIRELLA #1

It’s been 50 years since Vampirella first graced the comic page. Now, Dynamite Entertainment reintroduces the fan favorite anti-heroine with Vampirella #1. The story picks...

Review: RESONANT #1 A Sensational Way To End The World

Intriguing and exciting in equal measure, Resonant from Vault Comics has plenty to keep a reader engaged. A masterful first issue and a must read.
Darryll Robson
Darryll Robson
Comic book reader, reviewer and critic. Waiting patiently for the day they announce 'Doctor Who on The Planet of the Apes'.
COMIC REVIEW DIGEST, sign up today! At Monkeys Fighting Robots, we strive to talk about ALL aspects of a comic book, instead of just giving you a recap of the story.
  • Did you notice how epic the colors were?
  • That was a wicked panel layout by the artist!
  • What was the letterer thinking?
  • How did this comic book make you feel?
  • Most importantly, should you buy it?

Every Wednesday you will receive an email with our latest reviews and analyses, as well as our original comic strips and exclusive editorial content.
Thanks for signing up!