‘SUPERGIRL’ S4 Ep. 1 Review: “The American Alien”

- Advertisement -

Supergirl returns to the CW with a new time slot and a solid new story. “The American Alien” sets up a clear new path for the rest of the year. This episode is a great example of how a show should set the table for the season. While there’s an episode-centric storyline, fans know what to expect from the rest of the season. And if season four is as smart and polished as its first episode, fans are in for a treat.

This season of Supergirl starts in a comforting, optimistic place. Like its fellow CW series The Flash, Supergirl is strongest when it keeps a light tone. That said, it’s not as if “The American Alien” is nothing but hugs. The premiere pits Kara’s optimism against a host of new problems, embodied by the alien-hating terrorist twins. She also has a conflict with a now pacifistic J’onn, as they debate the state of human-alien relations. “The American Alien” touches on all these big, hefty ideas, but leaves room for plenty of development. While there’s a clear standalone plot with protecting the now-exposed President, Supergirl effortlessly teases what’s to come.

The political parallels work really well for this episode as well. Last season stumbled a bit with Morgan Edge, its bland Trump-esque villain. However, the mysterious anti-alien vigilante is a much more interesting antagonist. The anti-alien sentiments running through this episode are reminiscent of classic X-Men issues. The conflict around humanity’s acceptance of aliens is a great well to pull from. It’s a clear parallel to the disturbingly large alt-right movement in America, but it’s also clearly defined by the show’s lore. Supergirl has refined the way it tackles political issues, in a far stronger way.

Melissa Benoist as Kara Danvers, CW’S SUPERGIRL

- Advertisement -

Melissa Benoist as Kara/Supergirl, CW’S SUPERGIRL (copyright Bettina Strauss/The CWThe plot lines of the side characters work great as well. The way Kara and J’onn butt heads works really well, based on their history and new status. While Alex’s leadership of the D.E.O. isn’t showcased much, her conflict with Braniac helps to ground both characters for the season. The many levels of Luthor deception at play keeps the episode intriguing, as we’re always struggling to tell where Lena stands. All of the main characters in Supergirl get a strong storyline that doesn’t distract from the hero’s main exploits.

What’s not quite as polished is Kara’s new protege, Nia. While newcomer Nicole Maines does a stellar job as the up-and-coming reporter, the importance of her character isn’t evident. The idea that Kara has now become Cat Grant because she has a mentee isn’t as fleshed out as the show seems to think. That’s not to say that Kara won’t become more like Cat, or that Nia has no potential. But in an episode with many fleshed-out storylines, Nia’s is the only one that clearly needs further development.

Overall, “The American Alien” embodies the best elements of Supergirl. It expertly weaves its political interests into a compelling, natural conflict. All of the characters have interesting storylines we can follow into the rest of the year. Not only is this an fun standalone story, but it’s also a great precursor for what’s to come. It’s unclear how every character will fit into the upcoming conflict – particularly Nia – but it’s an exciting journey to be on.

SPOILERS: It will be especially fun to see how Russian Supergirl factors into everything. When she’s done tunneling under trains, of course.

Save 50% on graphic novels, statues & more!


Review: SPIDER-MAN #1 – J.J Abrams And Henry Abrams Take Spidey In A Bold New Direction

Spider-Man #1 by J.J. Abrams, Henry Abrams, Sara Pichelli, Elisabetta D'Amico, Dave Stewart and Joe Caramagna is an intriguing and beautifully illustrated book that...

Review: Depression’s Effects On Relationships Explored In MIDDLEWEST #11

MIDDLEWEST's angsty protagonist Abel is on a mission to find a way to deal with the uncontrollable power inside of him. Led into The...

Review: THE BLACK GHOST#1 Excellently Mixes Noir, Mystery and Vigilantes

The Black Ghost #1, published by ComiXology, and created by Alex Segura, Monica Gallagher, Marco Finnegan, George Kambadias, Ellie Wright and Taylor Esposito perfectly...

Review: YEAR OF THE VILLAIN: LEX LUTHOR #1 – Another Year, Another Ode To A Classic Villain

Year Of The Villain: Lex Luthor #1 is a strong collaborative effort that is a true celebration of one of the most complex villains...

Cosmic Ghost Rider Gets Gamma Bombed In Our AVENGERS #24 Exclusive Preview

Avengers #24 hits your local comic shop next week on September 25, but thanks to Marvel Comics, Monkeys Fighting Robots has an exclusive four-page...

Review: BLACK HAMMER: AGE OF DOOM #12-The End of an Epic

With Anti-God threatening existence once again, Abraham Slam, Golden Gail, and company are forced to make a difficult choice in Black Hammer: Age of...

Review: The Cavalry Arrives In ABSOLUTE CARNAGE #3

Absolute Carnage #3 continues the series’ exceptional start and the whole team continues to impress

Review: An Ending And A New Beginning In FAITHLESS #6

Faithless #6 from BOOM! Studios, is a thought provoking, love letter to fashion, theatre, and Art. A gorgeous end to the first, exhilarating arc.
Jon Barr - TV Editor
Jon Barr is a comedian and TV Phanatic. Yeah, he meant to spell it that way. It's like the Philly Phanatic, like from Philadelphia, because he's from - you get it. He loves good TV & mocking bad TV. You can find him all over the web.


If you want your BUSINESS to be part of something bigger than itself, you might be a good fit to partner with Monkeys Fighting Robots.

'SUPERGIRL' S4 Ep. 1 Review: "The American Alien" 3


'SUPERGIRL' S4 Ep. 1 Review: "The American Alien" 4

Are you a creator looking for a review of your book?
Use the form below to end us a message.

Are you a fan of the website and have a comment, question, or concern? Drop us a line, and we will gladly answer all your questions.


Monkeys Fighting Robots is looking for passionate writers to drive the site’s coverage of the comic book industry. Authors will be responsible for a particular niche, providing reviews, opinion and news coverage, while building a reader community using his or her multimedia storytelling skills. The best candidates have solid writing skills, WordPress knowledge, and are engaged on social media. Do you love comic books and have a strong opinion, then we would like to speak with you.

'SUPERGIRL' S4 Ep. 1 Review: "The American Alien" 5


COMIC REVIEW DIGEST, sign up today! At Monkeys Fighting Robots, we strive to talk about ALL aspects of a comic book, instead of just giving you a recap of the story.
  • Did you notice how epic the colors were?
  • That was a wicked panel layout by the artist!
  • What was the letterer thinking?
  • How did this comic book make you feel?
  • Most importantly, should you buy it?

Every Wednesday you will receive an email with our latest reviews and analyses, as well as our original comic strips and exclusive editorial content.
Thanks for signing up!