Review: DOCTOR WHO “Rosa” – History Supersedes Sci-fi

FIRST IMPRESSION

"Rosa" strays away from what modern Doctor Who fans are used to for a well-meaning episode.
Directing
Writing
Acting
- Advertisement -

During the Doctor’s travels, he (now she) has met many historical figures and seen many important events. In the latest episode the adventure focuses more on historical events than sci-fi antics.

The Doctor has been attempting to bring her new companion back to Sheffield. Unfortunately, they land in Montgomery, Alabama just before the famous Bus Boycott instead. They meet Rosa Parks (Vinette Robinson) and discover she is surrounded by artron energy. More than that, she’s attracted the focus of another intergalactic traveler (Joshua Bowman).
Doctor Who
“Rosa” was one of the most anticipated episodes in the new series because of its co-writer Malorie Blackman. Blackman is a celebrated writer in the UK, specializing in written novels for children and young adults. Racism and prejudice is a theme she likes to examine so it is no surprise she wrote an episode about one of the most famous Civil Rights activists.

Modern Doctor Who have made episodes focusing on historical figures – Agatha Christie, Vincent van Gogh, and William Shakespeare being central in episodes. But there was always a sci-fi element to the story. Van Gogh was plagued by a monster only he could see, and the disappearance of Agatha Christie was due to an alien wasp. “Rosa” aimed to be more educational, being close to events and the Doctor and the companion have to ensure history stays on course.

Doctor Who
Picture Shows: Ryan Sinclair (TOSIN COLE), Martin Luther King (RAY SESAY)

- Advertisement -

Doctor Who was originally meant to be an educational show that would teach children about history. During the First Doctor’s run there were historical episodes about Marco Polo, The Aztecs, and the Romans. In these episodes, there was no alien or sci-fi threat. “Rosa” is a homage to that kind of episodes and it continues Chris Chibnall’s back-to-basics approach, stripped down, simple stories.

There is a sci-fi enemy in the form of Krasko. He attempts to make small changes to events so that would have a big effect later on. The Doctor and her companions have to make sure history stays on course. It’s a small story with big implications. Rosa Parks and all the residents of Montgomery do not realize they are in a bigger story which is refreshing for Doctor Who.
Doctor Who
The episode also looks at how racism affects Ryan and Yasmin. Ryan gets a harsh lesson when he is polite to a woman and suffers the full force of a racist onslaught. Both companions suffer at the hands of segregation laws and policies that dominated the Deep South. They have a moment together talking about how the modern day racism they experience. The episode acknowledges that there are still issues involving racism in the modern day, though there’s been massive progress since the ’50s.

“Rosa” also had a few comedic moments. The best came when Ryan and Graham interrupt the bus driver James Blake (Trevor White), uses his racism to their advantage. Ryan also speaks using London terms like ‘bruv’. The episode references the Doctor’s new gender as well, and how she’s not used to it. But another joke where Graham pitches the iPhone falls like a lead balloon.

During the Steven Moffat era Doctor Who was becoming formulaic. Chibnall has brought new life to the series, using the franchise to different stories. It is refreshing to see Doctor Who downplay the sci-fi for a change. “Rosa” is a strong episode to show to younger children.

TRENDING THIS WEEK

video

Kelly Sue DeConnick Talks CAPTAIN MARVEL Behind-The-Scenes

Kelly Sue DeConnick answers YOUR questions about writing for Captain Marvel, seeing Marvel Studios' 'Captain Marvel' for the first time, and who she would want Carol to team up with.
video

Looking back with the DEATH OF CAPTAIN MARVEL | Marvel’s Pull List

Celebrate Marvel’s 80th Anniversary with the Pull List as we take you back to the 1980’s! Ryan & Tucker break down THE DEATH OF CAPTAIN MARVEL, THE SENSATIONAL SHE-HULK #1, SQUADRON SUPREME #1 and DAREDEVIL #181! ► Subscribe to Marvel: http://bit.ly/WeO3YJ Follow Marvel on Twitter: ‪https://twitter.com/marvel Like Marvel on Facebook: ‪https://www.facebook.com/Marvel For even more news,…

ARCHIE COMICS Solicitations For August 2019

Check out the gallery below to see the new Archie Comics digests, comics, and graphic novels arriving in comic book stores in August 2019. To pre-order these comics, contact your local comic book shop by using the Comic Shop Locator or online at the Archie Comics Shop. Information listed below is subject to change. JUGHEAD THE HUNGER…
video

Marvel 101: Do You Really Know Boom Boom?

Tabitha Smith couldn’t wait to explode onto the scene as the mutant hero Boom Boom. This week on Marvel 101, get ready to detonate, shatter, and generally cover your ears because this girl is ready to ignite.

Interview: Tom Taylor Talks DCEASED & FRIENDLY NEIGHBORHOOD SPIDER-MAN

Monkeys Fighting Robots sat down with Tom Taylor at MegaCon 2019 and talked about the writer's current superhero horror comic DCEASED, as well as...
video

DC Daily Ep. 175: Who is the MVP of DARK NIGHTS: METAL?

For even more DC Daily, be sure to subscribe to DC Universe at https://yourdcu.com/ytdcd175 Today on DC Daily, we’re chatting about the epic conclusion to DARK NIGHTS: METAL and answering the question, who is the MVP when it comes to defeating Barbatos? Plus, we talk to Dan DiDio on what else is in store for…

Review: Overman Fights For The Reich in FREEDOM FIGHTERS #6

Overman faces the Freedom Fighters! During World War II, the Freedom Fighters fought against the Nazis to try and stop the Reich. Just when they...
video

Captain Marvel | War of the Realms Ultimate Comic #4

Captain Marvel is no stranger to war, but the War of the Realms is pretty strange, and Carol has never faced any foe like the dreaded Frost Giants! Captain Marvel is no stranger to war, but the War of the Realms is pretty strange, and Carol has never faced any foe like the dreaded Frost…
Avatar
Kieran Freemantle
I am a film critic/writer based in the UK, writing for Entertainment Fuse, Rock n Reel Reviews, UK Film Review and Meniscus Sunrise. I have worked on film shoots. I support West Ham and Bath Rugby. Follow me on Twitter @FreemantleUK.