Review: Disaster on Demand in BAD LUCK CHUCK #1


BAD LUCK CHUCK #1 is an interesting start for this new series. The story is much so that readers may have trouble keeping up. Despite some missteps, there's a lot more that works than that doesn't.
- Advertisement -

In Bad Luck Chuck #1, the new title from writer Lela Gwenn on Dark Horse, we’re introduced to Tashi Charlene ”Chuck” Manchester, a walking bad luck magnet. So much so, in fact, she’s managed to turn it around into a pretty lucrative business prospect.

A new client contracts Chuck’s “disaster on demand” service in this energetic debut. However, her new customer may not be on the up-and-up.

The Writing

The writing in Bad Luck Chuck #1 is fun, above all else. The work is extremely energetic, pushing the story forward at high pace from the beginning.

Chuck is a fun character, embodying a lot of your classic, low-rent P.I. tropes. She’s cynical, blunt, and seemingly only motivated by cash. As for her powers, they’re not so much her own “bad luck;” rather, bad luck seems to happen to those around her, and she uses that to her advantage. What differentiates her from a character like Domino, though, is that Chuck’s powers seem genuinely supernatural. So much so, that she surrounds herself with rabbits’ feet, clovers, and other charms, just to keep it under control. It’s an interesting concept, always keeping an element of spontaneity and unpredictability in the story.

- Advertisement -

While Bad Luck Chuck #1 is a fast-paced story, that can actually work to its disadvantage at times. Primarily, there’s the fact that the book doesn’t really establish the persona of our lead. We know she has her powers, but we don’t get much else as far as motivation, background, or personality.

Certain plot threads seem a little underdeveloped or arbitrary at points. For example, why Chuck’s new client chose her is not really clear. Then, later in the book, Chuck’s charge seems indifferent about leaving her adopted “home.”

The Artwork

Matthew Dow Smith’s artwork is charming in Bad Luck Chuck #1. He employs a sketchy, rough look to the book, which works alongside the tone of the storytelling.

You lose a degree of detail with the sketchier style, and some poses may feel a bit awkward. However, it’s a nice effect. The artwork offers an impression, rather than a literal recreation of life, and it’s pleasing to the eye.

The color work by Kelly Fitzpatrick works nicely alongside Smith’s pencils. The colors appear flat at first glance, complimenting the sketchy art. Upon closer inspection, though, readers can pick up on more subtle details of Fitzpatrick’s work, especially in illuminating characters’ faces.

Final Thoughts

Bad Luck Chuck #1 is a solid start to this new series. While the details might be a bit fuzzy, the larger work is a fun, fast-paced, and engaging read.


Review: UNEARTH #1 – Plunging Into a New Horror Series

Something is clearly not right in the small Mexican town of Mitlán Itzá as Unearth #1 sets the stage for a twisted blend of...

Review: Can Batman & The Spectre Keep it Together in DETECTIVE COMICS #1007?

Batman and The Spectre’s uneasy truce holds as they search for Detective James Corrigan in Detective Comics #1007. Time’s running out, though, as the...

The Joker Gets Two New Comics In October

Fans of DC's Clown Prince of Crime got some big news this week: two new Joker projects are hitting the stands this October (joining...

Review: Eddie Brock Can’t Run From His Past In VENOM #16

Eddie Brock's ghosts continue to haunt him in Venom #16.

Review: SECOND COMING #1 is a Divine Comedy

Second Coming, the new book by Mark Russell, is going to offend a lot of people. The concept alone had rattled some cages when...

Review: STAR WARS: AGE OF RESISTANCE: CAPTAIN PHASMA #1- A Galaxy Far Less Interesting

It’s hard not to feel sympathy for the character Captain Phasma. Not that she was dealt a particularly difficult lot in life, but the...

Review: We Could Use a Few More Pages for THE QUIET KIND

In many ways, The Quiet Kind by Chuck Brown, with art by Jeremy Treece and Kelly Williams, is an inversion of the clichéd “chosen...

Review: RESONANT #1 A Sensational Way To End The World

Intriguing and exciting in equal measure, Resonant from Vault Comics has plenty to keep a reader engaged. A masterful first issue and a must read.
David DeCorte
David DeCorte covers comic book, entertainment, pop culture, and business news for multiple outlets. He is also a sci-fi writer, and is currently working on his first full-length book. Originally from San Diego, he now lives in Tampa.
COMIC REVIEW DIGEST, sign up today! At Monkeys Fighting Robots, we strive to talk about ALL aspects of a comic book, instead of just giving you a recap of the story.
  • Did you notice how epic the colors were?
  • That was a wicked panel layout by the artist!
  • What was the letterer thinking?
  • How did this comic book make you feel?
  • Most importantly, should you buy it?

Every Wednesday you will receive an email with our latest reviews and analyses, as well as our original comic strips and exclusive editorial content.
Thanks for signing up!