Review: DOCTOR WHO “The Ghost Monument” – A Unique Continuation For The New Series

FIRST IMPRESSION

A solid little episode with some robust effects and Lovecraftian style story.
Acting
Directing
Writing
- Advertisement -

Last week’s Doctor Who episode, “The Woman Who Fell to Earth,” ended on a big cliffhanger. The episode saw the Doctor and her new companions floating in deep space in what is essentially a two-part episode. That story line is continued in this week’s episode, “The Ghost Monument.”

After last week’s events, The Doctor and her companions are rescued by two spaceships competing in a race to a planet that is out of orbit. On this lifeless planet The Doctor, her companions and the two pilots (Susan Lynch and Shaun Dooley) are tasked to complete the final leg of the race and find the titular Ghost Monument.

Clearly, the Doctor Who production team had a lot of money to spend for this episode. “The Ghost Monument” was mostly filmed on location in South Africa, and the CGI and special effects were really impressive for a show which has a weak reputation on that front. The spaceships were almost cinematic in quality, and the cinematography was of the highest order. The only weak part was one of the spaceships enters the planet’s atmosphere.
Doctor Who
“The Ghost Monument” is a quest narrative where the Doctor and the companions have to go from A-to-B. This is unique in modern-Doctor Who where it is usually the Doctor comes to a location where trouble is happening, and he has to investigate what’s happening. The Doctor and the companions need to survive a hostile planet as they race to the monument.

The episode also had a Lovecraftian quality. The planet has the ruins of a civilization – there are buildings and boats but no signs of life. There are guard robots, and the water is filled with flesh-eating bacteria. It was wonderful for Doctor Who fans that like this type of fiction. When The Doctor finds records about what happened to the civilization, it reveals that “The Ghost Monument’s” ties to “The Woman Who Fell to Earth” were deeper than first thought. This scene was reminiscent to the scene in Lord of the Rings where Gandalf read the Dwarfs’ records in Moria.

- Advertisement -

The quest narrative allows for some character growth – although it’s the one-off characters, Angstrom and Epzo getting most of the attention. Angstrom was the richer character because she came from an impoverished planet and winning the race would be her ticket out, and she would be able to see her family again. Epzo was an arrogant rogue who does not play well with others.

Doctor Who
The Doctor (JODIE WHITTAKER), Graham (BRADLEY WALSH) – (C) BBC / BBC Studios – Photographer: Simon Ridgway

That said, the Doctor Who mainstays do have a chance to shine as well. Whittaker impresses when she has a verbal sparring match with Epzo on his ship. This led to some of the episode’s wittiest moments. There was also some desperation in Whittaker’s Doctor towards the end of the episode, and there was a nice little touch when she says “Come to Daddy” because even she is unsure what prefixes she should use.

Ryan (Tosin Cole) and Graham (Bradley Walsh) show that despite not having advance educational backgrounds they are still logical when they are given a task by the Doctor. Yaz (Mandip Gill) got to reveal a bit about herself when speaking with Angstrom. Ryan had a fun moment when facing the robots, showing off his FPS skills.
Doctor Who
Chris Chibnall is going for a back-to-basics approach – telling straightforward stories, and it acts as a good entry point for new audiences. There are no signs of an overarching storyline yet. Chibnall also has some fun twisting some tropes in the show like Graham asking how they can understand alien languages and they needed to be a different expectation since the companions haven’t entered the Tardis yet.

Chibnall’s Doctor Who reboot continues on a strong footing. “The Ghost Monument” is atmospheric and different enough to make it stand out because of its type of narrative and world building.

TRENDING THIS WEEK

MEGACON 2019: A Funny, Heartfelt Q&A with Zachary Levi

Even as Megacon 2019 wound down at the Orlando Convention Center on Sunday, Zachary Levi kept the energy level high during his Q&A session. Levi,...

Review: STAR TREK THE Q CONFLICT Soldiers On

Star Trek The Q Conflict issue 4 has finally found a story worthy of such a momentous crossover of characters

ARCHIE COMICS Solicitations For August 2019

Check out the gallery below to see the new Archie Comics digests, comics, and graphic novels arriving in comic book stores in August 2019. To pre-order these comics, contact your local comic book shop by using the Comic Shop Locator or online at the Archie Comics Shop. Information listed below is subject to change. JUGHEAD THE HUNGER…
video

Captain Marvel | War of the Realms Ultimate Comic #4

Captain Marvel is no stranger to war, but the War of the Realms is pretty strange, and Carol has never faced any foe like the dreaded Frost Giants! Captain Marvel is no stranger to war, but the War of the Realms is pretty strange, and Carol has never faced any foe like the dreaded Frost…

Review: The Tragedy of Astrid Arkham in DETECTIVE COMICS #1004

The plot thickens in Detective Comics #1004, as we learn Astrid Arkham’s origins, and the root of her hatred for Batman. As the daughter of...

Review: FAITHLESS #2 Will Seduce You

Faithless from BOOM! Studios is one of the most intriguing, visually stimulating, and exciting comics on the shelf.
video

Marvel 101: Do You Really Know Boom Boom?

Tabitha Smith couldn’t wait to explode onto the scene as the mutant hero Boom Boom. This week on Marvel 101, get ready to detonate, shatter, and generally cover your ears because this girl is ready to ignite.
video

Cartoonist Kayfabe: Director’s Audio Commentary: X-Men: Grand Design- Second Genesis issue 1

Ed's X-Men comic is nominated for a 2019 Eisner Award and the boys decided to dissect the comic page by page to point out all the stuff you may not have noticed on your first reading. Snail Mail! Cartoonist Kayfabe, PO Box 3071, Munhall, Pa 15120 Grab your "Frederic Wertham can eat a [email protected]%" T-shirts,…
Avatar
Kieran Freemantle
I am a film critic/writer based in the UK, writing for Entertainment Fuse, Rock n Reel Reviews, UK Film Review and Meniscus Sunrise. I have worked on film shoots. I support West Ham and Bath Rugby. Follow me on Twitter @FreemantleUK.