Review: SUPERMAN YEAR ONE #3 Brings the Limited Series to a Rushed Close


The conclusion to Superman's First Year rushes to the end by adding a little too much story.
- Advertisement -

Superman makes his debut in Metropolis!

When Superman Year One was first announced, I was honestly worried. Frank Miller was never one to stop making Superman an unlikable hero during his Dark Knight Trilogy, so the worry was he’d present a story that would make Clark look more like that version.

Instead, we had gotten a rather human story of Clark growing up in Kansas with his friends and family. Instead of becoming a journalist, he heads to the Navy, where he learns of the more supernatural parts of his world when he finds Atlantis. By the end of that story, he stays with the people after defeating a mighty sea creature after donning the uniform we all know and love. How will that soon change as his first year comes to a close?

Superman Year One #3 cover

**Some Spoilers Below**

- Advertisement -



We open our tale with Lois Lane exploring the ocean in search of the Man of Steel. When she gets too close to Atlantis, they fire on her submarine. Before it’s destroyed, Superman comes in and pulls her to safety. Realizing he could no longer stay in Atlantis or the coast for that matter, he goes off to become a journalist. He eventually makes his way to Metropolis and begins to make waves as both Superman and Clark Kent. Soon after, Clark comes face to face with Lex Luthor, who tells him of a dangerous terrorist that controls their neighboring city: Batman.

Superman Year One 3 p1

This is probably the weakest of the three-part story. It feels as if they took two issues and stitched them together. The first half of this story is great with Superman’s integration into Metropolis. It wasn’t this grandiose final battle you see with most origin stories that would cause the world to look upon the new hero. Instead, it was Superman stopping robberies, domestic violence, and other street-level crimes. It was grounded and a breath of fresh air from most stories like this.

The problem sadly lies in the back half of the story with the introduction of Lex and Batman. If the story were to have ended with Superman meeting Lex for the first time and then he flies off into the sunset, it would have been an excellent end to the series. Instead, we have it so we can have an interaction with Batman. This part feels tacked on as a way to bring in World’s Finest. If it was an issue unto itself, it might work, but here it just feels like an afterthought.

Superman Year one 3 p2


John Romita Jr.’s art actually works really well here. With no alien creatures, he is able to take a more grounded style. The best panels more often focus on Clark Kent, such as him adopting his disguise and saving a child as he comes to Metropolis. That isn’t to say the action sequences with Superman aren’t amazing. Superman fighting the military in the opening looked badass. Add to it the excellent color work of Alex Sinclair, the art of this finale goes above and beyond.

Superman Year one 3  p3


While I found the first two issues as strong retellings of the Superman origin story, the conclusion feels rushed. While there are definitely parts that work really well for Superman’s start, the forced inclusion of Lex and Batman feels like an unnecessary afterthought. Romita and Sinclair provide an excellent look for the final issue, staying grounded in the world of the Man of Steel. Of all the DC Black Label titles, this one stands out as a more hope-filled entry. Overall, the series a very welcome addition the Superman Mythos. I just wish it had a smoother conclusion.

Save 50% on graphic novels, statues & more!
Jose "Jody" Cardona
A New Jersey-born geek with a vast knowledge of DC Comics. He's a lover of movies, comics, stories, and hopes that one day he'll become a Jedi.


If you want your BUSINESS to be part of something bigger than itself, you might be a good fit to partner with Monkeys Fighting Robots.

Review: SUPERMAN YEAR ONE #3 Brings the Limited Series to a Rushed Close 5


Review: SUPERMAN YEAR ONE #3 Brings the Limited Series to a Rushed Close 6

Are you a creator looking for a review of your book?
Use the form below to end us a message.

Are you a fan of the website and have a comment, question, or concern? Drop us a line, and we will gladly answer all your questions.


Monkeys Fighting Robots is looking for passionate writers to drive the site’s coverage of the comic book industry. Authors will be responsible for a particular niche, providing reviews, opinion and news coverage, while building a reader community using his or her multimedia storytelling skills. The best candidates have solid writing skills, WordPress knowledge, and are engaged on social media. Do you love comic books and have a strong opinion, then we would like to speak with you.

Review: SUPERMAN YEAR ONE #3 Brings the Limited Series to a Rushed Close 7


COMIC REVIEW DIGEST, sign up today! At Monkeys Fighting Robots, we strive to talk about ALL aspects of a comic book, instead of just giving you a recap of the story.
  • Did you notice how epic the colors were?
  • That was a wicked panel layout by the artist!
  • What was the letterer thinking?
  • How did this comic book make you feel?
  • Most importantly, should you buy it?

Every Wednesday you will receive an email with our latest reviews and analyses, as well as our original comic strips and exclusive editorial content.
Thanks for signing up!