What Does LEGION OF SUPERHEROES #1 Mean For Rebirth?

[Editor's Note] If you like what we do, please consider becoming a patron. Thank you.

Become a Patron!

With Brian Michael Bendis’ Legion of Superheroes #1 finally hitting the shelves this week, many of us are wondering: What does this mean for DC’s big plans and Rebirth?

Of course, with many writers playing their cards close to the chest, and the finale to Doomsday Clock still on its way, we can only guess as to what the plan may be, but let’s have a refresher on what’s happened so far. We are going to do dive into Doomsday ClockDC Universe: Rebirth, and some of Bendis’ Superman, so beware of some spoilers.

Fact #1: Imra (Saturn Girl) reappeared in DC Universe: Rebirth alongside Wally West, creating the possibility for characters from previous continuities to return.

In DC Universe: Rebirth, we followed Wally West’s return to mainstream continuity. He gets pulled back to the land of the living by Barry Allen and tells us that someone has been messing with the timeline. The heavy implications are that Dr. Manhattan is the puppeteer pulling the strings. But Wally isn’t the only one who shouldn’t exist. Imra is seen, wearing her Legion flight ring and all, waiting to talk to Superman. The next time we see her in Batman/Flash: The Button, she is locked away in Arkham Asylum, as clearly her belief that there is another forgotten version of the world has been dismissed as delusion.

Fact #2: Imra and Johnny Thunder make their way onto the pages of Doomsday Clock.

Johnny Thunder, possessor of the Thunderbolt imp from the days of the Justice Society, is another character who has been dismissed as crazy for what he remembers. Escaping his old folks’ home, he later runs into Imra who has escaped from Arkham. They come face-to-face with Ozymandias, on his own quest to find our puppeteer, Dr. Manhattan. He locks them away again as they represent Manhattan’s meddling.

Fact #3: Imra disappears. (Again?)

In Doomsday Clock #11, Ozymandias says: “I would theorize that you’re no longer a part of this timeline, you just didn’t realize it,” and with that Imra disappears but her Legion flight ring is left behind. Unless something is done with Imra’s flight ring in the final issue, it seems her role in Doomsday Clock may just have been as a red herring.

Fact #4: Imra reappears, but she’s not the same Imra.

Finally, we come to Bendis’ run on Superman and to Legion of Superheroes #1. Imra is one of many Legion members who comes to welcome Superboy to the team, but she is not the same Imra as before and it is not the same team that we have known in the past. It seems that Bendis is taking the storyline in a bold new direction. We have new members on the team, a new base of operations and new versions of characters we thought we knew.

This begs the question: is Doomsday Clock going to be considered canon, or has it now become its own thing, since the rest of the DC Universe seems to be moving in a different direction? It would seem the Geoff Johns wouldn’t have bothered writing about Imra evaporating if he didn’t have continuity in mind. But does that just mean that the idea of “forgotten timelines” is over and that we’re going to be getting new versions of these forgotten characters?

Hopefully Doomsday Clock #12 provides some answers. Perhaps Doctor Manhattan has one last rewrite up his sleeve that will explain the new Legion.

Ultimately, it seems as though some of the original ideas for Doomsday Clock and the Rebirth storyline have been scrapped, while the spirit of what they were planning on doing remains intact. We don’t seem to be getting back the original, forgotten characters from the Legion of Superheroes, but a set of new versions that are now part of this Rebirth Universe. DC’s history and continuity is one of its most attractive qualities as a comic book universe. Will reintroducing old characters succeed in the way they hope, or is it the rich history and rapport between characters we miss as much as we missed the characters themselves?

Zac Owens
A world traveler and all-round nerdy guy, Zac is a DC fan and aspiring comic book writer. When he's not writing and editing for Monkeys Fighting Robots, he's carefully fitting more books onto his already-dangerously-overstuffed bookshelf. He lives in Halifax, NS for the moment. That is, until his Green Lantern ring comes in...


  1. Bendis. I can tell we have some fans here. I’m not one. Bendis of the “if continuity gets in the way, it has to go.” Just look at Young Justice. He has deaged Tim AND made him Robin at the same time he is Red Robin everywhere else and there is an active Robin. He’s deaged Cassie. Don’t start me on Connor. And if he bringing back Connor, which he did, why trap Jon Kent in a horrible volcanic prison and force him to age 5 years listening to Ultraman’s ramblings? BTW, Young Justice is part of the main continuity. First thing I checked.

    And outside panties. Yeah, he gave us a reason for Superman, but he’s back, tell Lois to give him the better suit. And why is Bats wearing an old suit? Is he than much of a fashion dork he takes cues from Smallville? Pfft.

    And the new Legion story is an abomination. Yeah, maybe I am biased having read each iteration from the original–the 70s on in real time, and finding back issues. Also, I don’t care they decided to make Lighting Lad black, but why does his costume have to look like a Black Lightning costume. Please.

  2. While I’m with you on her not being a red herring but it’s untrue that Bendis forced this change.

    Bendis said several times that he wouldn’t do anything to compromise Geoff’s work and is aware of DDC. He even backs it up with hints to the book (see my comment).

    Doomsday Clock itself has been foreshadowing the future being erased since issue 7 long before Bendis got the idea for a Legion reboot. She wasn’t erased by any action by Bendis, but by Manhattan meeting Superman.

    I’m sure he’ll give them closure and even let them co-exist like Legion of 3 Worlds or like Titans tomorrow and Batman Beyond, two futures that exist at the same time.

    Also, it’s actually a pretty good article.

  3. The idea of memories of forgotten timelines isn’t gone yet.

    Bendis himself is playing with it in young Justice with Tim getting flashes of Pre-Flashpoint YJ, with Conner and Bart remembering the timeline completely and also not existing in current history.

    Snyder also confirmed Barry and John or anyone in the present don’t remember the JSA.

    Oh and as for the Retroboot Legion, I’m guessing Geoff will have them appear one last time and may even co-exist with the new one like in Legion of Three Worlds. Similarly, the Titans of Tomorrow future and Batman Beyond future both interact with the main timeline but contradict each other.

    Overall Doomsday Clock is still canon and likely still in the future as Tom King is about to bring back the Button and link it to how Thomas is here. Both Snyder and Bendis have foreshadowed DDC as well. Besides what I already said, Bendis had Jon watch a Nathaniel Dusk film on Jor-El’s ship in Superman.

  4. Awful article! Saturn Girl is not a red herring…the timeline changed when Bendis made Jon the envoy to the Legion instead of Superman. She came back looking for Superman but that is erased since it’s now Jon and was never Superman in this timeline. It was because Doomsday Clock delays made them change plans and Bendis wanted his Legion.

Comments are closed.