Review: THE BATMAN WHO LAUGHS: THE GRIM KNIGHT #1 Shows Us Batman with Guns


An incredible story presented in the form of a thought experiment. Batman fans will see what the vigilante would be like if he killed his enemies.
- Advertisement -

We were introduced to the murderous Batman Who Laughs in DC’s DARK NIGHTS: METAL event when he attempted to wreck the Multiverse. This alternate version of Bruce Wayne was thought to have perished in the event’s climatic finale, but it appears he found his way into the world of Earth-One. Now he’s recruited the Grim Knight, another alternate version of Batman who is willing to kill.



This issue sets up a thrilling backstory to the Batman of another Earth, told through a conversation with his reluctant captive. This prisoner claims to be Batman’s friend, but the Grim Knight, as he is dubbed by the narrator, continues to push him along. As they navigate the Gotham streets we learn this version of Bruce Wayne made some startling life choices in contrast to his Earth-One counterpart.

Grim Knight and his captiveReaders learn the Grim Knight witnessed his parents’ murder in an alley much like Earth-One Batman. But instead of focusing that rage inward, this vigilante-to-be grabs the shooter’s gun and fires back. The scene leaves the reader speechless as Bruce’s sorrow slowly builds into a rage.

- Advertisement -

young Grim Knight young Grim Knight witnesses parents' murder young Grim Knight murders Joe ChillFrom that day forward the Grim Knight vowed to use whatever means necessary to take down criminals. This vigilante believed some criminals deserved death and added guns, knives, and other lethal weapons to his arsenal.

The Grim Knight is willing to cross the line Batman refuses to go near. And it is this characteristic that makes the Knight a perfect recruit for The Batman Who Laughs.

Scott Snyder and James Tynion IV’s story poses important questions to every fan of Batman: What would happen if Bruce killed criminals? Would we still respect him if he used guns? Readers will ponder these questions as they come to terms with a Batman who takes life and death into his own hands.


The issue’s main and variant covers captured the best aspects of this intriguing new version of the Dark Knight. Jock’s cover casts the Grim Knight in dark shadows to point out the mysterious nature of its main character.

At the same time, Gabrielle Dell Otto’s variant edition unveils this mystery by featuring an assortment of deadly weapons strapped to the Knight’s back, which emphasizes the stark contrast between him and the classic Earth-One Batman.


Eduardo Risso, Dave Stewart, and Sal Cipriano provide outstanding illustrations for the inner story. Risso’s pencils and Stewart’s colors compliment each other beautifully, highlighting the true horror of the Grim Knight’s backstory by using dark shading and realism in their illustrating. It’s also great to see the transition in artistic style between Bruce’s past and present, using hazier inks to give the appearance of his foggy memories and sharper images for the present events.

In addition, Cipriano adds great inflection to the lettering that emphasize key players in the story. Readers can rest assured the most important elements stand out in the dialogue.


THE BATMAN WHO LAUGHS: THE GRIM KNIGHT #1 introduces the Knight in near-perfect narrative fashion. It’s as if readers are invited to join the young Bruce in his horrific and violent journey toward becoming the Batman who kills. We’ll have to wait and see what plans the Batman Who Laughs has for this version of the Dark Knight.

What do you like or dislike about the Grim Knight? Let us know in the comments below!



Cartoonist Kayfabe: Director’s Audio Commentary: X-Men: Grand Design- Second Genesis issue 1

Ed's X-Men comic is nominated for a 2019 Eisner Award and the boys decided to dissect the comic page by page to point out all the stuff you may not have noticed on your first reading. Snail Mail! Cartoonist Kayfabe, PO Box 3071, Munhall, Pa 15120 Grab your "Frederic Wertham can eat a [email protected]%" T-shirts,…

DC Tales From the Vault – How MAD Became a Magazine – Part II

You're still here? Really?! Guess you actually want to see the second part of our DC Tales From the Vault on MAD. (There really is no accounting for taste.) DC Librarian Ben Le Clear continues his look at MAD's past, revealing what exactly prompted MAD's shift from a comic to a magazine. We'd like to…

Learn how to draw Squirrel Girl! | Marvel Quickdraw How-To

Learn to draw Squirrel Girl from "Marvel Rising" with this Marvel Quickdraw How-To! ► Subscribe to Marvel: Follow Marvel on Twitter: ‪ Like Marvel on Facebook: ‪ For even more news, stay tuned to: Tumblr: ‪ Instagram: Reddit: ‪ Pinterest: ‪

Jonathan Hickman On His Big Plans For The X-Men

Monday, May 13 was designated "X-Men Day" and now, one day later, comes some big X-news. We already knew Jonathan Hickman is returning to...

DC Daily Ep. 171: Batman Faces Off Against “The Demon Within”

For even more DC Daily, be sure to subscribe to DC Universe at Today on DC Daily, we’re chatting about the THE NEW BATMAN ADVENTURES episode, “The Demon Within,” and whether or not Batman is out of his element when confronted by magic. Plus, David F. Walker talks to us on what will be…

Review: Meet Mother Shark, The Ocean’s Memory Holder, In AQUAMAN #48

Andy, a.k.a. Aquaman, is nothing if not resilient in his quest to find his true identity. The recent events with the Old Gods helped...

MEGACON 2019: David Tennant on Nerd Culture, DOCTOR WHO’s Future, and Sexy Pants

Fans packed the main theater at the Orlando Convention Center on Friday, filling the room to near-capacity for a special Q&A session with David...

DC Daily Ep. 170: Can a Robot Batman Protect Gotham Better than the Real Batman?

For even more DC Daily, be sure to subscribe to DC Universe at Today on DC Daily, two of our super fans join us to discuss the BATMAN: THE ANIMATED SERIES episode, “His Silicon Soul” and whether or not Batman and his robot counterpart can protect Gotham together. Plus, we chat with toy designer,…
Corey Patterson
A comic book nerd and reviewer with a special interest in the underlying themes of superhero, sci-fi and fantasy stories. He enjoys writing for Monkeys Fighting Robots, Pop Culture and Theology and other publications.