Review: Can Batman & The Spectre Keep it Together in DETECTIVE COMICS #1007?


DETECTIVE COMICS #1007 is a bit of a letdown from the promise of our last issue. The stakes aren't really there, and the character designs have some kinks to work out.
- Advertisement -

Batman and The Spectre’s uneasy truce holds as they search for Detective James Corrigan in Detective Comics #1007. Time’s running out, though, as the mysterious cultists prepare to turn Corrigan into a sacrifice for their mysterious purposes.

The Writing

The writing in this issue is, generally speaking, a bit of a letdown from our previous issue.

As in Detective Comics #1006, the core of the story’s conflict is not between our heroes and the cultists, but between Batman and The Spectre. It’s whether the pair’s differing philosophies will ultimately tank their partnership. That conflict is downplayed here, though, with The Spectre pretty effortlessly giving in to Batman’s side. The stakes don’t feel particularly high for Batman, leading to a lack of concern for the reader regarding Corrigan’s predicament.

We learn from the first few pages of Detective Comics #1007 that the group who abducted Corrigan—The Cult of the Divine Hand—plans to capture and command The Spectre’s powers for their own purposes. It’s never really clear what those purposes are, though. We don’t know if they have designs on world domination, taking over Gotham…maybe just doing some magic tricks?

- Advertisement -

The issue’s climax also creates a mixed reaction in the reader. The mystery wraps up with surprisingly little fanfare, and the battle is so one-sided, the tension never really rises high enough to grip the reader. Overall, it feel like writer Peter J. Tomasi may have had a grander vision for this two-part story. That vision doesn’t come across in the final product, though.

Detective Comics #1007

Detective Comics #1007

Detective Comics #1007

The Artwork

Like the writing, Kyle Hotz’s visuals in Detective Comics #1007 don’t quite meet expectations. In my review of our previous issue, I mentioned Hotz’s work having a distinctly ‘90s feel to it. There’s a lot of charm to that aesthetic. Unfortunately, he also drags up some of the decade’s more infamous trends as well.

One notices a lot of awkward anatomy and unnatural poses throughout Detective Comics #1007. Batman’s torso looks something like a ball on a stick, while limbs bend at awkward angles throughout the book. Their might have been a stylistic intent behind the work, but that isn’t really a compelling-enough explanation. While Hotz manages to create some strikingly moody and spooky imagery, it’s not a consistent presentation.

David Baron’s colorwork on Detective Comics #1007 is the standout element. He uses a lot of vibrant, unnatural greens for The Spectre, while keeping everything else sufficiently moody. Baron goes for the full Halloween palette in coloring candlelit rituals and spooky, abandoned churches, and the effect works nicely.

Final Thoughts

Detective Comics #1007 is a bit of a letdown from the promise of our last issue. Not bad, but not a high point in Tomasi’s run thus far.


AfterShock Exclusive Preview: A WALK THROUGH HELL #12 – All Hell Breaks Loose

A Walk Through Hell #12 hits your local comic book shop on July 24, but thanks to AfterShock Comics, Monkeys Fighting Robots has a...

Advance Review: MIDNIGHT SKY #1 Creates An Intriguing Mystery And A Frightening World

Scout Comics' Midnight Sky #1, by James Pruett, Scott Van Domelen and Ilaria Fella is the start of brand new science fiction series that...

2019 Will Eisner Award Winners – The Complete List

The 2019 Will Eisner Awards were held last night at San Diego Comic-Con, and we have your complete list of winners below!

Review: GIDEON FALLS #15 Andrea Sorrentino’s Art Will Give You Nightmares

Gideon Fall #15 from Image Comics hits your local comic book store today; written by Jeff Lemire, with art by Andrea Sorrentino, colors by...


Wonder Woman Come Back to Me #1 is a reprinting of a classic tale of Diana once again diving into danger to save those she loves.

Hickman’s X-MEN Relaunch: Six Titles Coming Out This Fall

With just days until HOUSE OF X #1 hits store shelves, Marvel announced six brand-new ongoing series with a suite of all-star creative teams...

Review: DEAD END KIDS #1 Is A Somber Murder Mystery

Dead End Kids #1 is the new book from Source Point Press, written by Frank Gogol, with artwork by Nenad Cviticanin and letters by...

Review: We Could Use a Few More Pages for THE QUIET KIND

In many ways, The Quiet Kind by Chuck Brown, with art by Jeremy Treece and Kelly Williams, is an inversion of the clichéd “chosen...
David DeCorte
David DeCorte covers comic book, entertainment, pop culture, and business news for multiple outlets. He is also a sci-fi writer, and is currently working on his first full-length book. Originally from San Diego, he now lives in Tampa.


Please enter your comment!
Please enter your name here

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.

COMIC REVIEW DIGEST, sign up today! At Monkeys Fighting Robots, we strive to talk about ALL aspects of a comic book, instead of just giving you a recap of the story.
  • Did you notice how epic the colors were?
  • That was a wicked panel layout by the artist!
  • What was the letterer thinking?
  • How did this comic book make you feel?
  • Most importantly, should you buy it?

Every Wednesday you will receive an email with our latest reviews and analyses, as well as our original comic strips and exclusive editorial content.
Thanks for signing up!